Google Wants You to Out Good Sites. Really!

August 29, 2013
By Rhea Drysdale in SEO

Yesterday, Google’s Head of Web Spam, Matt Cutts, shared a link to a simple Docs survey where they’re asking webmasters to report high-quality small sites that you think should rank better. Yes, you heard that right. They want to know about GOOD sites!

If you’re like the Outspoken Media team, this was met with a company-wide, “wha?!”

While Google has been working hard over recent years to make it easier for the Web Spam team to connect with and inform webmasters, they’re usually looking for help outing bad sites. Whether it’s more support for reconsideration requests, new language on link schemes, or the recently released (then revoked, then re-released) Manual Actions report in Webmaster Tools.

Big Brands vs Small Business For years we’ve debated the issue of size and brand as it relates to rankings and it’s interesting to see that Google is now soliciting advice from the masses to test the quality of the algorithm. The debate has raged since 2008 (and before). I put the “big business vs little guy” graphic together (thanks Todd for sharing it so long ago) to help sort through some hypocritical assumptions on Google’s part when it comes to website behavior. We’re used to the perception that big brands get away with murder while small businesses suffer, but I’ve always believed that when it comes to the algorithm it really is a matter of brand signals versus the actual size of the brand. The more sites behave like actual businesses and invest in brand development, the more they’ll align with the direction Google is going with quality signals for greater search rankings.

However, as Barry Schwartz cited,

“only 30% of SEOs believe web site size does not matter in terms of rankings.”

At first we didn’t believe the survey was legit, because it’s so simple. How could Google possibly review all of the submissions they’ll undoubtedly receive? But truthfully, how many webmasters feel confident enough in their site’s backlink profile to submit?

Will you?

I know there are plenty of webmasters who believe in the legitimacy of their link building practices, but we typically find a history riddled with old, highly questionable links. At Outspoken, we work hard to rehab those efforts, but the threshold of what’s acceptable is changing daily with the most recent updates affecting press releases, guest posts, advertorials, and Twitter reacts to Google’s request for good sites:

UPDATE:

Sorting through yesterday’s tweets, it looks like Google had only received a couple hundred websites at that point:

Social Media
Social Media

Tim Ferriss & A New Era Of Astro-turfing?

on Jan 10 by Lisa Barone

I try to avoid social media on the weekends, both for my own sanity and the sanity of those around…

Online Marketing
Online Marketing

How Listening To Your Bubble Costs You Money

on Feb 15 by Lisa Barone

Google thought Google Buzz was a really smart idea. They thought so because Google employs geniuses and those geniuses got…

Internet Marketing Conferences
Internet Marketing Conferences

Building Buzz On Facebook: Getting Liked & Shared

on Mar 9 by Lisa Barone

Are you tired? Just a bit? I’m not going to lie, I’m borderline exhausted but we MUST PULL THROUGH! We…

HomeInternet Marketing BlogSEOGoogle Wants You to Out Good Sites. Really!
^Back to Top