Dear Brands, Be Edgy Without Being an Idiot

October 12, 2011
By Lisa Barone in Branding

Well, hello there. You look a little parched, like you could use some refreshment perhaps? How about a Dr. Pepper Ten to cool you down? Oh wait – sorry ladies, you’ll need to go powder your nose or go re-vacuum the stairs. This extreme beverage is only for men – no women allowed. I know because it says so right in the advertisement.

See?

As you might imagine, the angle Dr. Pepper has chosen to take for their 10-calorie diet soda drink has ruffled quite a few feathers. Okay, it’s ruffled a lot of feathers.

You could say it’s kind of a mess.

If the ad campaign was designed to get Dr. Pepper its fifteen minutes of Internet flame and fame, well then it certainly worked. But if they were trying to be clever or do market segmentation in any sort of intelligent way, they failed. And not at all because of the ad’s no-women stance.

Dr. Pepper failed the same way so many brands fail do when they get online.

  • They tried to be edgy and were just sad.
  • They tried to be polarizing and were just silly.
  • They failed because if they WERE going to offend anyone, that ad is more offensive to men than it is to women.

If there’s one thing I wish brands could learn is that you can be polarizing and still be intelligent. You can be clever without pandering to the lowest common denominator of man (or woman). You can be edgy without being an idiot or a royal bitch.

When you dumb down your marketing, you not only embarrass yourself, but your entire audience.

And that’s what I saw happening with Dr. Pepper’s ad for Dr. Pepper Ten. I wasn’t offended as a woman that this diet soda company was saying I couldn’t play. I was offended with how badly they were doing it.

Men shooting lasers in the woods?

Men making fun of women for watching chick flicks?

Men riding ATVs?

Really? That’s the best Man Zone content you’ve got? Come visit the Outspoken Media office in Troy and I’ll let you yank my pigtails, too.

Not that it’s uncommon, mind you. We saw a similar mess with Groupon earlier this year. They tried to be funny and polarizing and instead ended up begging for forgiveness with its tail between its legs when they couldn’t take the heat. Manly.

Being edgy/polarizing/remarkable without falling off the stupid cliff requires two things:

  1. A true understanding of your audience to know how they need to be pushed.
  2. A backbone.

It’s rare to find a big brand that has both.

When I think of brands who understand how to be polarizing and intelligent at the same time I think of Matt Inman. I think of Erika Napoletano. I think of Peter Shankman.

They polarize people by making intelligent arguments that speak to a common problem, experience or villain and strongly push people toward a certain belief. You wouldn’t find any of them dumbing things down for their audience or running through a forest with lasers.

Well, that’s not true. You might find Matt Inman in a forest shooting giant cats with lasers, but I digress…

At Outspoken Media, we’re also known for doing some pushing. Whether we’re outing brand jacking, calling out Google, mooting your excuses or getting everyone worked up over the topic of the day, we know how to play off people’s emotions to get them riled up. As a marketer, I’d argue that you have to. And it’s healthy.

“There’s nothing wrong with being edgy in marketing or purposely polarizing or pissing off your audience at times. There’s nothing wrong with Dr. Pepper going after a male audience and poking fun at us females. But there is something wrong with insulting everyone’s intelligence to do that. For me, that’s where Dr. Pepper went wrong.

I also found it interesting that Jim Trebilcock, executive vice president of marketing for Dr. Pepper, noted he wasn’t worried that women would be offended by the ad. He said that “women get the joke” and that their macho stance was “a way to start the conversation that can spread and get people engaged in the product”.

Jim – no one is engaged with your product right now. They’re engaged with telling you how dumb you are. And when they forget all about this flare-up in a week’s time, you won’t even have that.

In your attempt to be memorable, you actually became forgettable. That’s offensive.

Internet Marketing Conferences
Internet Marketing Conferences

Twitter Landscape – An Indepth View of the Twitter Ecosystem

on Mar 11 by Lisa Barone

Okay. I’m still raiding Michael Gray’s laptop while he’s on stage speaking. Let’s hope this goes okay. And it’s time…

Internet Marketing Conferences
Internet Marketing Conferences

The Search Crossover: Local, Mobile Social

on Oct 4 by Lisa Barone

Are you ready for some liiiiiiveblogging!  It may be a rainy Monday but all is right with the world here…

Online Marketing
Online Marketing

Day of Darkness: How Can You Help Fight SOPA/PIPA?

on Jan 18 by Lisa Barone

Much of the Internet is going dark today in protest of the Stop Online Privacy Act (SOPA) and its counterpart…

^Back to Top